History doesn’t usually announce itself with trumpets. Most of the time, it whispers. And right now, it’s whispering the same three things it whispered in 2007.
Housing. Oil. Jobs.
These three indicators moved in sequence before the last collapse. They appear to be moving in the same sequence now. Housing tends to stall first—it’s the most leveraged, most rate-sensitive, most emotionally charged asset class. Then energy prices convulse, reflecting demand destruction as economic activity contracts. Finally employment cracks, because companies don’t fire people until they absolutely must.
We appear to be between phase two and phase three.
The people running things see this. They have to. But they’re trapped in institutional theater. Powell’s “very happy” comment isn’t analysis. It’s performance. Central bankers must project confidence because confidence is the only thing keeping the credit flowing. Admit doubt, and the doubt becomes self-fulfilling.
So they wait. They monitor. They remain data-dependent while the data, at least to my eyes, suggests something else entirely.
Here’s what that something else looks like.
Manhattan real estate brokers have stopped being polite.
The emails now read like desperate pleas. Price reduced again. Seller motivated. Free two years of common charges. In Q3 2024, the median one-bedroom dropped to $815,000 according to available market data. Down 4 percent. Sales volume fell 12.7 percent. These aren’t crash numbers. They’re pre-crash numbers. The kind that tend to show up six months or so before the real pain starts.
Pending home sales declined 4.6 percent in October. That’s ten consecutive months. Ten.
New home sales collapsed 12 percent year-over-year. Inventory sits at 7.4 months of supply, up from 5.6 months last year. Builders who scrambled to meet pandemic demand now hold product they can’t sell. Construction loans come due regardless of whether anyone’s buying.
The math is brutal and simple.
A $400,000 mortgage at 3 percent costs $1,686 monthly. At 7.3 percent, it’s $2,741. The difference is $1,055 per month. For a household earning $75,000 annually, that’s not a stretch. That’s a wall.
Families are hitting that wall everywhere. They’re leaving California for Texas, New York for Florida, Illinois for Tennessee. Not because they want to. Because the arithmetic of staying became impossible. I’ve watched friends make this calculation. It usually takes about three months of staring at the bills before they call the movers.
Commercial real estate is arguably worse. Office buildings in downtown cores trade at 50 percent discounts from 2019 valuations. The work-from-home shift didn’t reverse. Companies discovered they don’t need Manhattan addresses. Now $1.5 trillion in commercial debt matures between 2024 and 2026. At current valuations, much of it probably can’t be refinanced at rates that make sense.
The Fed engineered this, at least in part. Eleven rate hikes. They had to fight inflation. But the inflation came from their own money printing, and the cure is killing the housing market.
Energy prices tell the truth when politicians won’t.
In summer 2024, West Texas Intermediate hit $83. By late autumn: $68. An 18 percent drop in weeks. Analysts blame oversupply and weak Chinese demand. They’re not wrong. They’re just incomplete.
Oil tends to crash when the economy stops burning it. Factories go quiet. Truck routes get canceled. Airlines reduce schedules. Consumers stop driving to malls that are already dying. The demand vanishes before supply can adjust.
In 2008, oil went from $147 to $32. Seventy-eight percent in five months. The violence of that decline measured the sudden stop of global commerce.
We’re not there yet. But the direction looks similar.
The International Energy Agency cut its 2024 demand forecast from 2.2 million barrels per day growth to under 900,000. That’s a significant revision. It suggests the recovery many expected failed to materialize.
European economic confidence fell eleven straight months through October, according to available surveys. Germany contracted two consecutive quarters. Switzerland and Sweden both posted negative Q3 GDP.
Switzerland matters. It’s where capital hides when trouble starts. If Switzerland is shrinking, trouble probably isn’t approaching. It likely arrived.
American shale producers generally need $70+ oil to survive. At $68, drilling stops. Financing dries up. The boom towns in Texas and North Dakota face bust. Jobs disappear. Tax revenues crater. Local economies that expanded rapidly now contract just as fast.
This is the insidious part. It’s not one sector failing. It’s three. Housing, energy, employment. Each makes the others worse. The Fed watches and raises rates because its models say inflation is the threat.
The models may be wrong. They were wrong in 2008. They could be wrong now.
Employment was the last excuse. The shield behind which optimists hid.
That shield is cracking.
Initial jobless claims hit 234,000 in late November. Six-month high. Three straight weeks of increases. In 2008, claims started around 320,000 and spiked to 665,000. We’re early in that curve. But the curve appears to be forming.
GM announced 14,000 job cuts in November. Cisco: 5,500. Spotify: 1,500. Citigroup plans 20,000 over two years. Amazon has shed 27,000 since 2022. Meta: 21,000.
These aren’t strategic restructures. These are companies seeing demand soften and cutting to preserve margins. When Cisco eliminates 5 percent of its workforce, it’s not because they found a better way to make routers. It’s because businesses stopped buying them.
Manufacturing employment contracted twenty straight months according to ISM data. Construction lost 34,000 jobs in October. Temp work—the first cut, always—dropped 150,000 since February.
The BLS headline numbers get the press conferences. The revisions get buried. The household survey shows weaker job creation than the establishment survey. History suggests the establishment survey tends to be wrong at turning points.
Unemployment is a lagging indicator. It was 5 percent when the 2008 recession officially started. It peaked at 10 percent in October 2009. By the time unemployment signals trouble, you’re already in it.
The jobs being created now are part-time, low-wage, without benefits. Gig work doesn’t pay mortgages. Real wages fell three straight months. Workers fall behind while productivity rises.
This matters beyond spreadsheets. Employment is identity. It’s family stability. Mental health. Community. The opioid epidemic followed manufacturing decline. Despair follows job loss. I’ve seen it in my own hometown. The plant closes. Then the pills appear. Then the funerals.
We’re building toward another wave. The warnings flash. Powell calls it happiness.
More...
