You see, a few weeks ago I wrote a quasi-humorous columnsuggesting that China's social credit system was being informally implemented right here in the USA courtesy of such fair and balanced organizations as Google, Facebook, YouTube, Amazon, Microsoft and Apple.
"Think about it," I wrote at the time. "The U.S. is in the grip of a progressive mobocracy trying to standardize everyone's thoughts and actions. Leftists insist you support their side or they will find some way to hurt you – economically, politically, socially, educationally, or in your career.
"Little by little, incrementally, the progressive dominance of politics, schools and the media means conservative thought is being suppressed (at best) or punished (at worst). Don't believe me? Just consider the number of people afraid to admit their support for Trump lest they have their grades penalized or their job jeopardized or their car keyed. If you're caught wearing a MAGA hat in public, you're practically taking your life in your hands.
"Conservatives are heckled in the streets, harassed in restaurants, and have their homes or businesses sabotaged. In school, children are bullied or expelled for expressing Christian opinions or objecting to 'transgender' athletes dominating girls' sports.
"In an unregulated (and some might argue, unhinged) invasion into our privacy, the Google/Facebook/YouTube/Amazon/Microsoft/Apple cabal is listening and tracking everything: what we say, what we research, where we travel, what routes we take, what we buy, and everything else about us. China does the same thing."
OK, that's what I wrote (among much else) at the beginning of June. It was supposed to be something of a joke, for Pete's sake. I had no idea additional evidence would crop up as fast as it did
Within days of that column, I started collecting headlines that this kind of dystopian scheme is being implemented right here in America, culminating with screaming headlines on Drudge a few days ago about China's social credit system coming to Silicon Valley. Consider these stories:
- YouTube engages in yet another round of content crackdown
- Why technology favors tyranny
- YouTube to ban "hateful," "supremacist" videos
- Google's latest search algorithm change hurts web traffic for Daily Mail and others
- California is launching a creepy "Cradle to Career" data system to track everything about children
- YouTube crackdown blocked history teachers who shared archive videos of Hitler
- State moves to take over Christian school: Dozens of agents stage raid over fake rumor, then demand it "relinquish its moral standards"
- A conservative Michigan woman claims she was dismissed from the Miss World America pageant because her tweets about black-on-black gun violence and refusing to try on a hijab were deemed "offensive, insensitive and inappropriate"
- Woman loses job for "teaching while conservative": "I did not wear an American flag for fear of being sort of too subversively patriotic"
- Harvard prof: School is "reprogramming students" into "right-thinking" grads it "wants them to be"
- The five stages of homofascism now complete
- Now totalitarian "social-credit scoring" hits America
I could go on and on, but you get the point. And I haven't even touched such issues as YouTube censoring videos by Dennis Prager and Steven Crowder. You've seen the media and leftist activists go after Laura Ingraham, Tucker Carlson, Sean Hannity, Rush Limbaugh and of course WND.
The scary thing about America's credit scoring system is that it's outside government control. Don't misunderstand: I don't like government control, but at least in theory we have constitutional protections (notably the First and Second Amendments). In the eyes of a constitutional republic, a liberal and a conservative are given exactly the same treatment.
But social scores offered by left-leaning corporate tyrants means everyone and anyone they don't like are scored low, and the sky's the limit. If you fall outside the narrow judgmental tyrannical expectations of the Google/Facebook/YouTube/Amazon/Microsoft/Apple cabal, you're toast.
As a Fast Company article explained: "If current trends hold, it's possible that in the future a majority of misdemeanors and even some felonies will be punished not by Washington, D.C., but by Silicon Valley. It's a slippery slope away from democracy and toward corporatocracy."
In China, surveillance allows the authorities to rank individuals by degree of "trustworthiness," and to send anyone it deems unreliable to reeducation camps. When will this happen in America? You can dismiss this as just conspiracy-theory nonsense if you like, but darn it, those conspiracy theories have a nasty habit of coming true.
"Surveillance is … dangerous in formal democracies," observes Pierre Lemieux. "One reason is that yesterday's extreme cases often become today's standard practice. … Until about 2010 … the FBI had more DNA records than the Chinese government (which started later in the competition), although the collection is proceeding so fast in China that America doesn't 'win' the race anymore; per capita, the two countries are now about equal."
The problem with a surveillance state, Lemieux argues, "is not so much what it knows as what it can do with what it knows. The Surveillance State is dangerous not so much because it violates some standard of privacy, but because surveillance fuels control."
Move over, George Orwell. There's a new game in town.
No comments:
Post a Comment